In my log for Taipei Story I mentioned how the movie continues the theme I don’t see in a lot of Western media of homesickness for adolescence. Sure, there’s Western coming-of-age stories that end with a “After we all go to college will we still visit during summer?”, but there’s something more to it that I couldn’t really put my finger on with East Asian media. Now, after watching 5 more months of movies I think I have a better idea of it.
It isn’t really a homesickness for older times, I think its deeper than that. I get the feeling that the East Asian outlook on things is that after awhile you get sort of /stuck/ at some point, and you can’t really change as a person, almost to a painful degree. That point is usually somewhere at the end of adolescence. When you’re a kid you get to do whatever, trying to experience all that life has to offer before you become a boring adult with a job, with a personality that reflects what you experienced as a kid.
Different East Asian media explore this very differently, too. Taipei Story was about people reconnecting, realizing they’re different people now. In the Heat of the Sun was about kids being as carefree as they could, to their detriment. Tampopo was a bit different, having a man who messed something up once and didn’t believe he could try it again. Gundam, Ideon, and Dougram (and MANY other mecha shows, I’m sure) all have kids have their innocence stolen from them by war.
Evangelion however, takes a different approach. Yes, you may believe that you can’t change who you are and you may be happy with it, but you CAN change. It’s painful, and you may end up destroying the majority of the world’s population, but you CAN do it. Evangelion has a more ‘complete’ picture of this pain, but that doesn’t mean its approach is better or anything, it’s simply a different approach.
Evangelion of course isn’t the only story that I’ve seen use this approach. Ping Pong the Animation is also very similar, for example. While I’m writing this I’ve just thought of the only piece of Western media that I think gets close to what I’ve been talking about: season 1 of True Detective. I’m not sure to what degree though, I’d have to rewatch it.